The assignment template “for helping students read, comprehend,
and respond to texts” was an informative overview of key concepts that should
be covered as we teach our students to engage the reading process.
As I did an initial scan of the article, I wondered if the
template, applied as a whole, would be a little overwhelming to try to cover
within every reading/writing unit. While each stage of the reading/writing
process, as it was laid out, seemed to be quite extensive and thorough (a
definite upside of the template), I could also see it being quite a slog to get
students through. However, the overview of the process, outlined at the
beginning of the article, is what really changed my mind. I think the template
makes a lot of structural sense. It covers parts of the reading/writing process
that it is easy for a teacher to forget (especially in the pre-reading and
post-reading sections). What the template lacks in conciseness it makes up for
in comprehensiveness.
If I were to apply this template as a teacher, I think I
would present only the basic outline of the process to my students at the
beginning of the course without providing a ton of detail up front. Then, as we
work through our first reading/writing assignment, I would help them flesh out
what each of the steps of the outline looks like as it applies to our
assignment, providing as many details and different approaches and resources as
they find helpful. I could see this first assignment taking some time as the
students slowly become familiar with each of the steps in the writing and
reading process. As we move into our second reading/writing assignment, I would
then start letting them make choices about how they want to engage each of the
steps of the process (e.g. choosing between mapping the organizational
structure or descriptive outlining when considering the structure of the text).
Slowly, as we continue working through units, the students would become more
familiar with the template and be able to engage each step of the process
however they find works best for them.
No comments:
Post a Comment